The Pros and Cons of Black Mulch

Mulch can save you a lot of time, effort, and money in the long run, as it’ll keep weeds at bay and moisture in the soil, especially when it’s hot and dry. But should you use black mulch? And what is black mulch, anyway?

What is Black Mulch?

Although it’s mainly used to refer to dyed bark mulch, black mulch can refer to bark mulch, plastic mulch (landscape fabric), or rubber mulch. They’re all used to suppress weeds and to keep moisture from evaporating, although black wood mulch looks nicer in a yard or garden.

Black bark mulch is made from recycled wood from old furniture, pallets, construction, and demolition. Because it’s not very attractive as is, it’s dyed black using carbon-based dyes. (Fresh wood chips can’t be dyed.)

Black plastic mulch is made from geotextiles (AKA polypropylene) and can last several seasons. It can kill weeds by shading them and heating the soil hot enough that it kills any existing weeds underneath. It can also prevent weeds from germinating. The drawbacks are that once soil builds on top, weeds can sprout in that soil, and it’s not recyclable or biodegradable, although manufacturers are starting to offer biodegradable plastic mulches at a higher price.

Rubber mulch is made from recycled, shredded tires. It’s supposed to be nontoxic and safe for garden use, but it contains several toxic contaminants [PDF] that are harmful to the environment, humans, and pets. It is also highly flammable and difficult to extinguish. And insult to injury, they’re not even as good as other mulches in suppressing weeds.

The Pros of Black Bark Mulch

  • Like most mulches, black bark mulch will shade the ground and make it harder for weeds to germinate and grow.
  • Black bark mulch has the same advantages of most mulches — it’ll shade the ground, making it harder for weeds to germinate and grow. It’ll also keep water from evaporating from the soil so you can water less even in dry weather.
  • The black colour will heat under the sun, so the soil underneath will warm up faster and garden plants will recover from winter quicker.
  • The colour is considered attractive and quality manufacturers use a carbon-used dye to colour it black. The carbon-based dyes are safe for your garden and are like what you’d find in ink and cosmetics. Low-quality and cheap mulches may be dyed with toxic chemicals.
  • Because the wood is treated, it decomposes slowly so it’ll last as long as the colour.
  • The Mulch & Soil Council seal means that the mulch has passed laboratory, greenhouse growth, and chemical testing. At the very least, you know there’s no CCA-treated wood contaminants.

The Cons of Black Bark Mulch

  • Depending on the source, the wood may have been chemically treated with creosote or chromated copper arsenate (CCA). CCA has been banned since the early 2000s, but it’s still present in any wood that was treated before then, especially in wood sourced from construction and demolitions. AVOID USING when sourced from construction and demolitions. If you decide to go with dyed bark mulch, go for brands certified by the Mulch & Soil Council.
  • Recycled wood from pallets may have been contaminated by chemical spills when transporting chemical agents.
  • You can’t recycle or compost black bark mulch. The treated wood will prevent it from breaking down soon (and you don’t want those toxic chemicals in your soil), and currently there’s no process for recycling. You cannot add it to your yard waste bin. You will have to take it to your local waste management facility for disposal.
  • The wood colouring will fade over time, the time frame depending on the weather, rainfall, and sun exposure.
  • Any dye not soaked into the wood will come off in your hands. Wear gloves when handling.

pile of black mulch on lawn dropped off by truck

Black Mulch FAQs

Is Black Mulch Safe for Dogs?

Black bulk mulch that contains CCA or other toxic chemicals are bad news for dogs. But whether MSC-approved mulches are safe for dogs depends on the dog. They may be allergic to the wood, choke on it, or eat it, causing vomiting.

Some dogs won’t chew on mulch at all. Others will constantly chew on it. They may chew on mulch out of boredom, a lack of nutrients in their diet, or just because they like to chew and don’t see a difference between your black mulch and a nice stick.

When in doubt, go for an untreated pine or cedar mulch or a black plastic mulch-like landscape fabric.

Do NOT use cocoa bean mulch (this is extremely toxic for dogs and cats, for the same reason dogs can’t eat chocolate) or rubber mulch (besides toxic chemicals, it’s a choking hazard).

Is Black Mulch Safe for Your Vegetable Garden?

Black bark and rubber mulches are not safe for your vegetable garden, but black plastic mulch is.

If you don’t know what chemicals are in the black bark mulch, then keep it far away from anything you’d eat. The same goes for rubber mulches. You don’t want your vegetables drawing up any toxic chemicals, and the toxic chemicals may stunt plant growth to begin with.

However, food-grade black plastic mulch is fine to use in your vegetable garden. Organic, regenerative farmers use it to suppress weeds around their longer-growing crops, like tomatoes, cucumbers, and squash.

Can Black Mulch Cause a Fire?

Black bark mulch is not more or less likely to cause a fire than other types of wood mulch. Wood mulch can ignite when the conditions are just right. A scorching hot day, deep wood piles with lots of microbial activity, and dry wood on top. Sun glinting off broken glass, a cigarette, or fire pit can also cause fires.

The Massachusetts Gov website has a handy PDF on how to prevent mulch fires.

Black plastic mulch, being made from propylene, won’t start a fire, and if it did, the plastic would melt and the fire would go out quickly.

Rubber mulches are highly flammable, and they’re difficult to extinguish once a fire starts. They’re best avoided.

Feel free to check out our comparison guide of Vigoro Mulch vs Scotts Mulch to see which is a better option for you.

Read our related post “How Much Does a Bag Of Mulch Weigh? (Scotts, Vigoro, etc…)” here.

Leave a Comment